There’s something undeniably soothing about sinking into a cozy murder mystery. With an easy-going vibe and a tendency to evoke nostalgia, these tales often feature minimal violence after an initial shocking event, making them the ideal escape from the pressures of modern life. While a few characters might meet their demise, viewers can rest assured that the villains will typically face justice, and harmony will be restored by the time the credits roll. It’s no surprise that this genre thrived during the pandemic, as countless viewers turned to classics like “Murder, She Wrote” and “Columbo” for comfort. Remarkably relaxing, even contemporary shows like “Poker Face” have helped me through bouts of insomnia in the past.

Agatha Christie: The Queen of Cozy Mysteries

Although the phrase “cozy mystery” wasn’t used during her lifetime, Agatha Christie is often hailed as the originator of this genre. She introduced the iconic detective Hercule Poirot in her debut novel “The Mysterious Affair at Styles” in 1920, eventually producing 65 more novels, 14 short stories, and plays like the legendary “The Mousetrap.” In 1930, she unveiled another beloved character, Miss Marple, in “The Murder at the Vicarage.” Christie’s staggering popularity solidified her status as the best-selling novelist of all time. Typically, a classic Christie mystery involves a clever crime set among the affluent, where every character harbors both motives and alibis. Part of the joy comes from piecing together clues before the detective unveils the solution at the conclusion. Christie’s work lends itself well to film adaptations, with numerous versions appearing globally. Here, we’ll focus on the top 12 Agatha Christie films in English.

12. The Mirror Crack’d (1980)

Directed by Guy Hamilton, “The Mirror Crack’d” is a unique entry, as the filmmaker, also known for his Bond films, confessed to not being a fan of Christie’s novels. This conflicting perspective results in a film that feels slightly tongue-in-cheek, which clashes with the serious nature of a plot centered around a fragile actress suspected of a poisoning scheme. While Angela Lansbury’s Miss Marple takes a backseat after an accident, Inspector Dermot Craddock (Edward Fox) takes charge amid a Hollywood location shoot gone awry. The film, set in 1953 yet resembling 1980, features a cast of fading ’50s stars, adding a layer of camp that, while sluggish, still provides some sparks, particularly from Liz Taylor and Kim Novak’s sharp exchanges.

11. Crooked House (2017)

Published in 1949, “Crooked House” is cherished by Christie herself, yet it took nearly 70 years for it to hit the big screen. Written by Julian Fellowes, this adaptation is perhaps the darkest Christie film to date, deviating from the typical cozy fare. Private detective Charles Heyward (Max Irons) investigates the suspicious death of his ex-girlfriend’s grandfather among a cast of manipulative relatives. Despite its subdued tone, “Crooked House” showcases solid production values, thanks largely to Glenn Close’s flamboyant performance and Gillian Anderson’s humorous portrayal, ultimately delivering a satisfying yet flawed mystery.

10. A Haunting in Venice (2023)

Set against the backdrop of the hauntingly beautiful Venice, Kenneth Branagh’s “A Haunting in Venice” adapts Christie’s “Hallowe’en Party” with a supernatural twist. Here, Poirot, now semi-retired post-World War II, investigates a ghostly mystery at a reputedly haunted palazzo. The film’s darker tone offers a change of pace from typical adaptations but struggles to maintain momentum throughout. While the visuals are stunning, the plot lacks the intrigue expected from a Christie. Nonetheless, performances from Tina Fey and Michelle Yeoh bring depth to the otherwise predictable narrative.

9. Murder at the Gallop (1963)

The second of four Miss Marple films featuring Margaret Rutherford, “Murder at the Gallop” maintains a light, engaging tone under George Pollock’s direction. As Miss Marple investigates a murder she witnessed, the plot unfolds with familiar dynamics and whimsical character interactions, particularly with her companion, Mr. Stringer. Rutherford’s dynamic chemistry with Stringer, portrayed by her real-life husband, adds heartfelt warmth to the mystery, delivering an enjoyable installment of the series.

8. Endless Night (1972)

One of Christie’s most praised novels, “Endless Night” marks a significant departure from her traditional style, delving into psychological horror through the eyes of a young chauffeur. Sidney Gilliat’s adaptation gives it a distinctly Hitchcockian vibe, supported by an eerie score and an unsettling atmosphere. Although the film’s pacing lags at times, it ultimately provides a thought-provoking exploration of identity and desire.

7. Murder on the Orient Express (2017)

Kenneth Branagh’s adaptation of this iconic story incorporates CGI to deliver a dramatic avalanche scene, a choice that detracts from the claustrophobic intensity found in Sidney Lumet’s earlier version. While Branagh’s portrayal of Poirot showcases both humor and somberness, the cast—including Michelle Pfeiffer and Johnny Depp—lacks the same vibrancy as those in the 1974 classic. The film remains entertaining yet muted, drawing from a well-loved narrative.

6. And Then There Were None (1945)

René Clair’s adaptation of Agatha Christie’s best-known novel, “And Then There Were None” (released as “Ten Little Indians” in the U.K.), sets a benchmark for Christie adaptations. Its masterful blend of suspense and dark comedy maintains a balance of intrigue and entertainment, making it a fun watch. The cast excellently portrays a group navigating a sinister mystery, contributing to its status as an enduring classic.

5. Murder She Said (1961)

Opening with a lively score, “Murder She Said” introduces Margaret Rutherford in one of her beloved portrayals of Miss Marple. The film diverges from the original novel, presenting the titular detective as a proactive participant in the story. This humorous spin transforms the detective genre, yielding a charming and engaging experience, despite Christie’s reservations about Rutherford’s portrayal.

4. Evil Under the Sun (1982)

Similar to Roger Moore’s take on James Bond, Peter Ustinov’s Poirot graces “Evil Under the Sun” with a playful demeanor. The light-heartedness of the film doesn’t deter from a cleverly crafted mystery set in a stunning island resort. The vibrant cast, coupled with entertaining character dynamics, delivers an engaging cinematic experience, rich with humor and intrigue.

3. Murder on the Orient Express (1974)

Sidney Lumet’s adaptation of “Murder on the Orient Express” stands as a classic. The film features an impressive ensemble cast, including Sean Connery and Ingrid Bergman, who collectively enhance the story’s enigmatic atmosphere. Lumet adeptly navigates the complexities of Christie’s narrative, providing a treasure trove of memorable performances and unexpected twists.

2. Witness for the Prosecution (1957)

Billy Wilder’s adaptation of Christie’s stage play “Witness for the Prosecution” showcases Charles Laughton in a brilliant role as a barrister immersed in a convoluted murder case. The interplay between Laughton, Tyrone Power, and Marlene Dietrich creates a compelling mix of drama and humor, which carries the film to its captivating conclusion, marred only slightly by a rushed denouement.

1. Death on the Nile (1978)

In the beautifully shot “Death on the Nile,” Peter Ustinov shines as Hercule Poirot, providing a warm yet astute portrayal surrounded by a star-studded cast. The film’s enchanting visuals, coupled with a tight plot involving love and betrayal, yield a captivating experience that has earned its place among the best adaptations of Christie’s work. For those looking to explore these captivating mysteries, many are available on streaming platforms.